Why Natural Gas Water Heaters Are the Best Option for Your Home

Are natural gas water heaters the best option for your home? Check out the advantages over other fuel types, benefits, about standard, tankless and energy efficient water heaters.

Water heating for domestic use can consume an enormous amount of energy. And if you have a large household that uses lots of hot water, then it’s going to tell on your energy bills. Generally, water heating takes a large chunk of your energy bill, about 18% after heating and cooling.

Therefore, seeing how much energy water heating could potentially consume, it’s no surprise that you might be considering other options. The method you choose for your water heating is one way to conserve energy. In other words, the type of fuel that the water heater uses is important.

Advantages of natural gas

  • Natural gas is the cheapest of all available fossil fuels.
  • It is considered as a clean energy alternative.
  • It burns clean and provides a lot of power.
  • Produces less greenhouse gases than other fossil fuels.
  • Natural gas is safer than propane; it dissipates more quickly.
  • No storage needed, delivery is reliable.
  • It can be used even during the power outage.

Natural gas water heaters

No doubt, there are several fuels used to heat water, but one of the most efficient is natural gas. No matter the sort of heater you prefer, whether conventional heating using tank-type heaters, energy star, or tankless, natural gas is the way to go. The tankless heaters with the condensing technology are the most efficient with the best performance, longer warranties, and lifespan.

So, natural gas is a great source of fuel for water heaters because generally, it is more cost-efficient than electricity, and it is available to many homes. You may get rebates from some utility companies if you switch from electric to gas water heaters, or buy the Energy Star qualified model. All things being considered, natural gas heaters have several advantages over other kinds of water heaters.

Standard tank water heaters

Gas water heaterGas water heater

A great number of conventional tank-type water heaters is powered by natural gas. Basically, standard heaters have a storage tank and have been around for ages. They have a proven technology, are reliable and supported by an extensive service network that is operating for decades.

A gas burner continuously heats the cold water in a storage tank from the bottom of the unit. The gas water heaters traditionally have a lifespan of 8-12 years, while the warranties are from 6 to 12 years, depending on the protection and element quality.

Again, most residential water heaters are of the capacity ranging from 30 to 60 gallons, where the 50-gal models are the most popular. For large and demanding homes, there are water heaters with a capacity as high as 120 gallons. To be clear, standard tank heaters powered by natural gas are often more affordable than other types. They are quite simple to install and maintain; however, they are less efficient all round. Besides, there are newer water heating methods that are ultra-efficient. These are known as condensing water heaters, and good examples are AO Smith Vertex and Polaris.

Energy star water heaters 

Energy Star water heaters have higher energy-efficiency than the standard models with lower energy factors. They have better insulation, advanced ignition system (direct electric or hot surface), and are often power vented. These water heaters can save you a reasonable amount of money yearly on heating costs, plus rebates from the utility company and tax breaks from the government (when applicable). Also, you should probably find out about possible rebates for Energy Star water heaters in your location.

Tankless water heaters

Now, tankless heaters are the newest and most effective in water heating technology. They do not have storage tanks but heating water on demand and delivering in endless supply. Tankless are small but powerful and high efficient.

For instance, the Rinnai RUR199iN natural gas tankless water heater is an ultra-high efficient and ultra-low NOx tankless water heater. It is run by natural gas and has a condensing technology with dual heat exchangers. What this means is that it delivers maximum efficiency and has an Energy Factor of up to 0.96. It delivers plenty of hot water to several showers at the same time, plus it uses the recirculation system for faster hot water delivery.

Some things to consider before deciding to go tankless

  • Type - Do you prefer the electric or gas-powered model? It is important to consider the requirements for each before choosing. For instance, venting for the gas and dedicated circuit breaker and proper voltage for the electric model. The recommendation is to buy a condensing tankless water heater powered by natural gas, such as the above Rinnai RUR199.
  • Demand - Would a single unit be sufficient for the entire house, or will it serve only one or more bathrooms and a kitchen? Buy a tankless water heater with the modulating gas valve and high turn-down ratio so it can provide either small amount of hot water for a single faucet or higher volume in multiple applications.
  • Location - Where you’re going to install the water heater is also important. This could either be indoors or externally.
  • Life span - gas-powered tankless heaters have a long lifespan. So, if you need a water heater that lasts long and is backed by an extended warranty, you should probably consider tankless. 
  • Installation - Consider hiring a highly rated plumber or electrician to do the installation.

Again, if you’re interested in tax rebates or Energy Star ratings, then you should avoid electric water heaters and go with the natural gas or propane.

Benefits of using natural gas water heaters in your home

Basically, if you have gas piped into your home, then installing a natural gas water heater is the best way to go. There are several reasons for this, and we’ll look at the top three below. These are:

  • Cost savings
  • Energy efficiency
  • Environmentally friendly

Cost savings

When compared with other fuels, natural gas is one of the least expensive ways to heat your water. And especially if it is piped into your home, you can enjoy this fuel without paying extra. If you’ve tried heating water with electricity, you will quickly notice the natural gas is significantly cheaper.

So, using a tankless natural gas water heater is a great way to cut down on your utility bills. An excellent example of the affordable tankless with a great energy factor and water flow rate is the Takagi T-KJr2-IN-NG. This water heater heats water quickly and efficiently and can produce enough for up to two bathrooms.

Energy efficiency

Now, we’ve already mentioned that water heating can take up a good portion of your utility bills. Therefore, if you want to bring down costs, a good place to start is with the water heater. Since natural gas is cheaper than electricity, you’re already cutting down on your energy use by switching over.

However, when you decide to install a tankless natural gas water heater, you get hot water on demand. This means that unlike with a storage tank, you’re not storing up hot water that isn’t used – so no standby heat loss. There is no wastage, even in flue gases. With the condensing heaters, the flue gases are used to preheat incoming cold water.

All the hot water that is produced is used up since you’re only producing what is needed. This makes any of the water heaters in the Rinnai RUR199iN Ultra Series an excellent choice.

Not to forget, natural gas water heaters are incredibly fast and heat water at a faster rate than electric water heaters, which is important where the increased recovery rate is needed. They produce flow rates that are higher than other methods, sometimes as much as 11 gallons per minute, such as in a case of the Noritz NRCP models. Also, it means that less time and energy is used heating water making natural gas water heaters energy efficient.

Environmentally friendly

Let’s face it, water heaters are not particularly environmentally friendly, but they are practical. That said, natural gas water heaters produce enough hot water for your home with low and ultra-low NOx emission levels. If you’re concerned about the carbon footprint, then a tankless natural gas water heater is the way to go.

How natural gas water heaters compare to other heating methods

So, you might be wondering about how natural gas water heaters fare when compared with other methods. It is reasonable to examine things clearly to help you make an informed choice. Below are some more popular methods of heating water, their benefits as well as their drawbacks.

Heat pump water heaters

Generally, heat pumps are energy efficient because of the way they function. They capture heat from ambient air and use it for heating water. Very little electricity is used up here, especially in the warm and mild climates, and when the electric heating elements are not used. However, some electricity is used to heat the water when the weather is cold, and heat pumps are not as efficient. This could be seen as a drawback.


  • Energy-efficient
  • Very cost-effective in the long run
  • Eco- friendly as no greenhouse gas is released to the surrounding


  • High initial cost
  • Humidity is reduced and cold air generated in the cost of capturing heat from the air, resulting in discomfort
  • Not suitable for extremely cold climates due to low efficiency

Solar water heaters

Interestingly, solar-powered heaters are becoming more popular in some parts. But the fact remains that they can only work in places that have lots of sunlight. And even then, it would have to be combined with other heating methods.


  • Energy-efficient and low operating costs as it uses free solar energy
  • Cuts down utility bills


  • May not be used as the only source of energy
  • Can’t be used in cold regions or when there’s no sunlight

Propane-powered water heaters


  • More energy efficient than natural gas as it delivers more BTUs and consumes less volume per hour
  • Propane burns without emitting toxic gases to the environment just as natural gas, they are both eco-friendly
  • Convenience. Propane is portable which makes it convenient for you when moving to a different area


  • Propane is more expensive than natural gas
  • Propane is heavier than natural gas and takes longer to dissipate in the air when released, making natural gas technically safer
  • Propane comes in portable canisters or tanks, but it isn’t quite so easy to refill. You’ll need to take your tank to a retail location or schedule a delivery. And if there’s a failed delivery, it could be a problem.

Are you considering converting from propane to natural gas?

Now, if you are already using a propane-powered water heater you can convert it to natural gas. However, you need to think about the cost, and the major one is to bring natural gas to your home. This is expensive, but taking into account that the operating costs are much lower, your investment will pay off in the long run. Especially when combined with the natural gas furnace.

The manufacturers will usually provide the conversion kits with the water heaters so by changing the burner/pilot orifice, thermocouple, thermostat, and adjusting the gas pressure, and the conversion can be done from propane to natural gas model (should be done by the licensed professional).

Are gas water heaters safe and can they explode

Natural gas water heaters are safe in general, as long as they are correctly installed by the licensed technician and per codes. DIY installation must be performed with extra caution to prevent any potential leak, mainly from gas connections and vents.

If the gas heaters are not adequately vented users can be exposed to dangerous carbon monoxide, which is also known as a silent killer.

Another danger is coming from the faulty pressure and temperature relief valve, which could lead to extreme pressure inside the tank and potential explosion.

If you need info on how to fix a gas water heater use this article.

How long water heaters can last

The lifespan of a natural gas water heater is around 10 years, while the warranty is between 6 and 12 years, depending on the quality of components and available features. For example, water heaters equipped with two anode rods, commercial-grade, or powered anode are those with a longer warranty.

What is the best natural gas water heater?

If money is not an object, look for the ultra-efficient and condensing water heaters from AO Smith, such as Vertex, or Polaris. The best gas models come with the high recovery, condensing technology, stainless steel components, and ultra-high energy factor of over 0.9.


Finally, natural gas has a lower cost, is eco-friendly, delivered to your home without interruption and hassle, and is energy-efficient. If you are thinking of installing a new water heater, a tankless natural gas water heater might be your best option. There are many options out there, where the models mentioned above are among the top ones: Rinnai RUR199 and Takagi T-H3.

On the whole, tankless natural gas heaters will save you the stress of high electricity bills. Also, you won’t need to bother about refilling propane tanks or canisters as the utility company provides an uninterrupted supply of fuel. Best of all, gas water heaters have a long lifespan, making it a natural choice for your home.

Leave a Comment

[ ? ]

Author Information (optional)

Submit Your Contribution

  •  submission guidelines.

(You can preview and edit on the next page)

Find Trusted Plumbers & Get Free Quotes

Popular articles